The menu at After The Fox in McHenry brings a mix of hearty American classics and tempting seafood bites that immediately stand out. The cheeseburger is as comforting as expected-juicy, well-seasoned, and layered with melty cheese on a toasted bun. The pub burger feels like a step up, bigger in flavor and portion, with that satisfying char-grilled taste that makes it a go-to choice for anyone craving something bold and filling.

Seafood lovers will find plenty to enjoy as well. The breaded calamari steaks are unique compared to the usual calamari rings, offering a thicker cut with a crisp golden coating that stays light while keeping the inside tender. They strike a nice balance between texture and flavor. The jumbo shrimp cocktail is another highlight-plump shrimp served chilled, pairing perfectly with a zesty cocktail sauce that has just the right kick.

For something a little more indulgent, the hot wings bring the heat. Crispy on the outside and coated generously in sauce, they carry a satisfying punch without overwhelming the palate. Each dish on the menu feels straightforward yet thoughtfully prepared, giving diners a variety of flavors to enjoy without straying too far from familiar favorites.